The original 1984 talk by elder poelman that was changed. His quote, mormon doctrine is 2 miles wide and an inch early church deep, is one of my favorites. Poelmans 7 october 1984 general conference address, the gospel and the church, with the article, elders address rewritten. In a 1984 general conference address elder ronald poelman said. I dont know about you, but of all of the members of the quorum of the twelve, richard g.
This statement, along with many others, is recast in the ensign version. The original 1984 talk by elder poelman that was changed to soften the message about moving beyond your need for the institutional church submitted 8 years ago by. Makes for difficult studying of an overly bland subject. Elder poelman october 1984 conference talk post by joel. April 1998 became emeritus so, at first glance, elder poelman went from speaking every two to 2. Occasionally, such traditions, customs and practices. Sep 24, 2004 i dont know about you, but of all of the members of the quorum of the twelve, richard g. This book has had a minimum of 57 different readers as there are various colors of highlighting and even pencil and ballpoint markings through out the text. Oct 09, 2014 the general thrust of the fair explanation of poelman isnt original.
Once you turn 31 you have to either move on to going to a regular family ward to a much rarer ward for singles 31 and older ward. Several years ago, elder ronald poelman of the seventy gave a talk in general conference entitled the gospel and the church. I recd the book quickly and all, but i could swear the ad said like new. In the book, oaks discusses the principle of being pure in heart, which is basically developing integrity, doing the right things for the right reason, keeping your intentions pure and selfless. The next day, he stood at the pulpit in the salt lake tabernacle and had his talk refilmed. The rewriting and refilming of elder ronald poelmans october 1984 conference address, originally a rare and inspiring defense of free agency, so that it. Click here to be taken to to read elder poelmans redacted talk it also has the published video. I wonder if this is in part the lingering influence of admiral hyman rickover. Poelman s sunday morn ing address, the gospel and the church, at october conference 1984 was the best they heard. Scott has always struck me as the sweetest and most patient.
And even though it is tucked away neatly on, it has set the internet on fire. Elder ronald poelmans 1984 general conference talk that told us that we should at some time be brave enough to take the training wheels off, and try the twowheel biking when we feel we are ready. Apr 11, 2006 elder polemans october 1984 talk the gospel and the church george orwells 1984 can be rather prophetic at times. Elder poelman october 1984 conference talk post by joel mon dec 17, 2018 8. I am currently rethinking everything thanks to your podcasts for helping me take stock of some items id totally overlooked in my mormonness. Ive recently, however, been pointed to the video of his original talk. They were willing to pay the price of bad press, so they ordered elder poelman to go back to the tabernacle, with the rewritten version in hand, and they dispatched a film crew to refilm that speech in the dark of night no announcement was made it was an attempt to deceive the masses. Previously, in my exploration of our changing church, i quoted from the october 1984 general conference address of elder ronald e. Poelmans 1984 conference talk was edited after delivery and rerecorded with a cough track. Poelman s wonderful, liberating talk in october 1984 general conference. In 1984, he delivered a controversial sermon in the lds churchs general conference which the church redacted before publishing biography. One of the stranger episodes of this type of dishonesty i am aware of involves a brilliant conference address given by elder ronald e. The best conference talk you never read pure mormonism. Elder poelman october 1984 conference talk original.
Two different version of this talk were distributed. Elder poelman october 1984 conference talk post by rose garden. The original 1984 talk by elder poelman that was changed to soften the message about moving beyond your need for the institutional church. Apr 11, 2018 click here to be taken to to read elder poelmans redacted talk it also has the published video click here to read part of peggy fletcher stacks original article about the redaction. The rewriting and refilming of elder ronald poelmans october 1984 conference address, originally a rare and inspiring defense of free agency, so that it became yet another cry for obedience. He learned about how syme and others were working to simplify newspeak. The original 1984 talk by elder poelman that was changed to. His book, an insiders view of mormon origins is a great summary of the skimmed over issues most members in the pews are unaware of. Poelman was born in salt lake city, utah to a latterday saint family. The gospel and the church brigham young universityidaho. Selected poems 19581984 john wieners, raymond foye on. I have no personal experiences or special information to back this up. His text was not editedhis ideas were turned inside out fletcher 1985.
Poelman of the seventy, messenger magazine, 20020722, archived from the original on 20071007. We learn in the sermon on the mount that it is the pure in heart who shall see god. Both the gospel of jesus christ and the church of jesus christ are true and divine, and there is an essential relationship between them that is significant and very important. Ashs first published book, shaken faith syndrome, is a michael. Keeping a diary in 1984 oceania is punishable by death, or at least by 25 years in a forcedlabor camp. Ronald eugene poelman born 19290510 has been a general authority of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints lds church since 1978. In book 1, chapter 5 of 1984, winston had lunch with his coworker syme at the ministrys cantina. Dec 01, 20 elder poelman in oct 1984 general conference gave a talk was silently but not unnoticably redacted about people getting to the point where they dont need the church.
Rickover is the man who invented nuclear powered submarines. Poelman the first quorum of the seventy general conference october, 1984. Poelman s 1984 conference talk was edited after delivery and rerecorded with a cough track. Poelman, speaking in conference on the gospel and the church, observes. Click here to read part of peggy fletcher stacks original article about the redaction click here to read side by side comparisons of elder poelmans two talks click here to read about euthyphros dilemma does god command because it is right, or is it right because god.
The original 1984 talk by elder poelman that was changed to soften the message about moving beyond your need for the institutional church submitted 8 years ago by canadianjohnson 9 comments. His text was not edited his ideas were turned inside out fletcher 1985. Elder poelman in oct 1984 general conference gave a talk was silently but not unnoticably redacted about people getting to the point where they dont need the church. The typical singles ward is a young single adult ward, meaning from 18 to 30. Elder polemans october 1984 talk the gospel and the church.
Elder poelmans 1984 talk miscellaneous mormon dialogue. Social science research council cochaired by elder launched a program to promote a dynamic life course approach by drawing on the unparalleled data archive of the michigan panel study of income dynamics. The 1984 missing poelman genereal conference address. Whats more, anyone seeking the video record of elder poelman s talk would find that poelman s segment had been pulled from the official church archives and replaced with a counterfeit. Mormonism and historycensorship and revisionhas the church. Elder poelmans gospel and the church ive written on elder poelmans october 1984 talk before, so i wont go into it again. Jul 11, 2010 elder poelmans gospel and the church ive written on elder poelmans october 1984 talk before, so i wont go into it again. Differences between the two talks are highlighted in red.
Ronald poelman censored general conference talk nov 16, 1984. As individually and collectively we increase our knowledge, acceptance, and application of gospel principles, we become less dependent on church programs. David michael, former host of the my book of mormon podcast. In october 1984 general conference, elder poelman gave a talk outlining the differences between the church and the gospel an amazing. Poelman, an emeritus general authority of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints and former. Controversial lds conference talk edited for publication the lds church has now released online text and audio editions of talks delivered at the churchs general conference last weekend, including a talk delivered by elder boyd k. Poelmans october 1984 conference sermon as published in the ensign the gospel and the church. The temple sits atop a hill, and its spire, topped by a figure of the angel moroni, towers 257 feet, visible to ships twentyfive miles at sea. Many of us were filled with joy and relief as brother poelman pointed out the distinctions between the gospel and the institutional church. Oct 09, 2010 this may be the first instance in 26 years when an lds conference talk was substantially edited for republication, the last being elder ronald poelmans october 1984 conference talk on the church and the gospel.
Church under condemnation for not remembering the book of mormon by nibley. Her book is no man knows my history was originally labeled antimormon lies, the book is now. It is by far the most informative piece the church has released on the subject. Poelman revises conference speech bmggy fletcher to many american saints, elder ronald e.
Mcconkie stated, men can get nearer to the lord, can have. Peggy fletcher stack wrote in sunstone at the time, immediately following general conference, those apostles who regularly deal with mormon apos tate groups pointed out to elder poelman that his remarks might by misinterpreted. Dec 14, 20 the lds church recently added a new page titled race and the priesthood to their website under the gospel topics section. In a 1984 general conference address elder ronald poelman said, sometimes traditions, customs, social practices and personal preferences of individual church members may, through repeated or common usage be misconstrued as church procedures or policies. According to wikipedia poelman spoke again in conference four and a half years later and didnt become emeritus until 1998. My book of mormon join me, marie kent, as i read through.
Poelman, a member of the first quorum of the seventy. Poelmans 1984 conference talk to be rerecorded with a cough track in order to hide the fact that changes had been made. Poelmans 7 october 1984 general conference address, the gospel and the church, with the article, elders address rewritten from. Poelman of the 1st q of the 70 in general conference of october 1984 1984 is ironically the title of the book by orwell, about this very kind of deception. In 1984, he delivered a controversial sermon in the lds churchs general conference which the church redacted before publishing. Poelmans general conference talk became the most famous casualty to date in the ongoing battle for control over the lifeblood of the church. Poelman both the gospel of jesus christ and the church of jesus christ are true and divine, and there is an essential relationship between them that is significant and very important. Nov 22, 2011 on 16 november 1984, the salt lake tribune broke a story about changes in first quorum of seventy member ronald e. Lets look at the three others who were called into the first quorum of the seventy with elder poelman. Obrien then forced winston to look at his horribly emaciated and. The rewriting and refilming of elder ronald poelmans october 1984 conference address, originally a rare and inspiring defense of free agency. Elder poelman october 1984 conference talk post by rose garden wed nov 25, 2015 8. Poelmans 7 october 1984 general conference address, the gospel and the church, with the article, elders address rewritten from conference version, by rodd g. Controversial lds conference talk edited for publication.
On october 7, 1984 an appropriately orwellian year, ronald e. Poelmans sunday morn ing address, the gospel and the church, at october conference 1984 was the best they heard. Elder poelman october 1984 conference talk original part 1. Elder poelman october 1984 conference talk page 3 lds. George orwells 1984 can be rather prophetic at times. Mormonism and historycensorship and revisionhas the. If you think the gutted 1984 talk of elder poelman is no big deal and the attempt to unite the church with the lord and to encourage dependence on the church is therefore a. Poelman s 7 october 1984 general conference address, the gospel and the church, with the article, elder s address rewritten from conference version, by rodd g. A favorite scriptural source for is the old testament book of leviticus.
Some have claimed that this was an effort to hide the fact that changes had been made. Unfortunately, institutions have a natural selfpreservationist instinct that seems to create a set of messages that are biased in favor of their own interests, and what is good for the church is not always good for the membership see, for example, the troubling story of elder poelmans talk in the of all years 1984 general. The language i quoted must have impressed others as well, because it appeared in the salt lake tribune and deseret news reports of the conference. The joseph smith seer stones that were used to translate the book of mormon and receive many of the. Pulling the race bandaid off rational faiths mormon blog. The idea for this book emerged in the early 80s when a committee of the u. It was in october conference of that year that elder ronald e.
The face of big brother, the leader of the party and a heavily mustached and ruggedly handsome man of about 45, appears on giant, colorful posters everywhere in airstrip one, oceania. Thus one of the most interesting and some would say most important conference talks of the latter half of the twentieth century simply disappeared down the. Capener, salt lake city attorney, said, it was my personal favorite of the conference. God inspired mormon, its chief compiler, to put into the book what we would need. In 1984, he delivered a controversial sermon in the lds churchs general conference which the. The general thrust of the fair explanation of poelman isnt original. Published on jul 14, 2006 in october 1984 general conference, elder poelman gave a talk outlining the differences between the church and the gospel an amazing talk. Click here to read side by side comparisons of elder poelmans two talks. The lds church recently added a new page titled race and the priesthood to their website under the gospel topics section. Poelman of the first quorum of the seventy ensign, nov. Poelman was born in salt lake city, utah to a latterday.
Why does the church heavily edit conference talks which are considered scripture after the fact, like president packers talk in 2010 or elder poelmans talk in 1984. Packer on homosexuality that has been the subject of public controversy among mormons and the general public. The first was given over the pulpit at general conference, the second was published in the ensign and on the official conference videotape. Elder poelman voluntarily edited his talk when he learned that some fundamentalist mormons were using his address as justification for their beliefs. Controversial lds conference talk edited for publication religion. Carlisle hunsakers removal from the university of utahs lds institute of. Poelman both the gospel of jesus christ and the church of jesus christ are true and divine, and there is an essential relationship. Apparently some of the brethren did not like what he said and had him redo his address. Ronald eugene poelman may 10, 1928 november 19, 2011 was a general authority of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints lds church from 1978 until his death. It is basically a handbook for hebrew priests and contains many rules, regulations, rituals. On 16 november 1984, the salt lake tribune broke a story about changes in first quorum of seventy member ronald e. This communication exchange highlights perhaps a good example.
217 532 1252 140 833 1028 1093 219 1090 1394 1394 911 890 521 495 756 1545 609 812 908 1475 359 682 577 1048 136 1163 1471 341 303 505 907 1306 1006 1264 952 761 1403